Critical Films of 2011
By Eric Schneider2011 featured an eclectic cinematic mix like we haven't seen in a long while. Werner Herzog explored the very beginnings of humanity, while Lars von Trier peered into its apocalyptic end. Kelly Reichardt hypnotically led a bonnet-wearing Michelle Williams into a wild frontier, while Cary Fukunaga put Mia Wasikowska through the emotional wringer in his gothic take on Jane Eyre. Pedro Almodóvar unveiled an unsettling new horror tale, while a silent film -- yes, a silent film -- both charmed and amazed us. There were even baseball and wrestling films that managed to avoid cliche and sentimentality. Like I said: an eclectic year.
With that kind of diversity, we each had films that particularly clicked for us. Adrienne McIlvaine appreciated the tension of women in desperate situations with The Skin I Live In and Meek's Cutoff. A globetrotting John Wilson gravitated towards more pensive fare with Cave of Forgotten Dreams and Uncle Boonmee Who Can Recall His Past Lives, a mesmerizing study of spirituality by Thai filmmaker Apichatpong Weerasethakul.
Josh Ralske fell for the unlikely charms of indies Rid of Me and Terri, and was disarmed by the psychological unraveling of the protagonists in Martha Marcy May Marlene and Take Shelter. Resident filmmaker Kristy Puchko was floored by the dark drama of We Need to Talk About Kevin, but blissfully transported by the gorgeous silent movie The Artist -- a marvel for even existing in the year 2011.
And me? I enjoyed watching a misfit band of noble samurai in 13 Assassins, and Hanna, the thrilling story of a girl taking on a cold, uncaring system with ferocity and style, all set to a killer score by The Chemical Brothers. I was fascinated as von Trier brought about the end of the world in Melancholia, and it was a glorious sight to behold.
| CRITICAL LIST | |
|---|---|
The ArtistMichel HazanaviciusA silent film that sings. >> |
|
Meek's CutoffKelly ReichardtA highly original and boldly minimalist film about life on the Oregon Trail. >> |
|
We Need to Talk About KevinLynne RamsaySwinton stuns in this thought-provoking exploration of a parent’s worst nightmare. >> |
|
Cave of Forgotten DreamsWerner HerzogThe inimitable Herzog explores the human experience using a novel application of 3D technology. >> |
|
Uncle Boonmee Who Can Recall His Past LivesApichatpong WeerasethakulA hypnotizing exploration of spirituality and the transitory nature of the soul. >> |
|
Win WinThomas McCarthyAnother earnest victory for writer/director Tom McCarthy. >> |
|
TerriAzazel JacobsAn insightful, funny, and brutally honest portrait of an alienated teen. >> |
|
Rid of MeJames WestbyReminds you why low-budget indie quirkfests exist. >> |
|
Martha Marcy May MarleneSean DurkinSmart, beautifully acted drama about a young woman's escape from a cult. >> |
|
13 AssassinsTakashi MiikeA gripping and uncharacteristically direct samurai epic from Japan's king of twisted cinema. >> |
|
Take ShelterJeff NicholsAn intriguingly ambiguous tale of one man's apocalyptic vision. >> |
|
MoneyballBennett MillerA pointed, authentic, and fun baseball movie. >> |
|
HannaJoe WrightWright reteams with Ronan for a thrilling modern-day fairy tale. >> |
|
MelancholiaLars von TrierA grandly ambitious and striking film. >> |
|
Jane EyreCary FukunagaThis surprisingly straightforward take on Brontë is elevated by its superb leads. >> |
|
The Skin I Live InPedro AlmodóvarShocking horror-thriller that dives beneath mysterious skin. >> |
|
A SeparationAsghar FarhadiA family drama with the tension of a thriller. >> |
|
![]() |
![]() |


