Music List

Chris Payne’s Critical Albums Of 2011

By Chris Payne

When I look back on my listening habits in 2011, they serve as a soundtrack to the year when I decided to take music journalism more seriously, in a sort of career-oriented way. Transitioning from a college radio music director to my current stint with Billboard, I found myself at least having to maintain awareness of all things "pop" in addition to whatever was hot at your typical indie record shop. Perhaps that's why I quieted the elitist inside me and included Adele and The Strokes, both of whom released albums I listened to a great deal.

If you asked me for my favorite indie label right now, I'd probably answer Slumberland, who continued their recent hot streak by releasing some fantastic records in 2011. The sophomore effort from Crystal Stilts and Veronica Falls' debut cracked my Top 10, and The Pains Of Being Pure At Heart's Belong came pretty close.

Given Zola Jesus' super-duper buzz band status, I approached Conatus with caution, but was quickly won over. Same goes for the Black Lips: working with Mark Ronson for most of Arabia Mountain, I was somewhat worried they'd give up the fuzzy-scuzzy thing and just start living it up in the DJ booth at celebrity parties. In the end, the record made it to #2 on my list, regardless of whether the latter actually happened.

Although I toyed with putting each of my top 4 records at the number one slot, it was James Blake's debut LP that ultimately claimed the prize. Perhaps it was all the terrible music people tagged as "dubstep" this year, or Blake's own dismissal of it in a Boston Phoenix interview. Or perhaps it was because his album was just so undeniably gorgeous - the sort of music that made me appreciate empty space so much more.

 

CRITICAL LIST

James Blake

James Blake
Dubstep's soulful new poster boy. >>

Arabia Mountain

The Black Lips
Mark Ronson heads to the Dirty South. >>

House of Balloons

The Weeknd
A skillfully experimental underground debut. >>

Bon Iver

Bon Iver
One-time woodland minstrel conquers the world. >>

In Love With Oblivion

Crystal Stilts
Sometimes-jarring but likeable history lesson of gloom. >>

Conatus

Zola Jesus
Goth kids of the 2010s, meet your leader. >>

Holy Ghost!

Holy Ghost!

Veronica Falls

Veronica Falls
Scottish indie kids explore goth-punk. >>

Angles

The Strokes
Is This It? Not quite, but close. >>

21

Adele
Promising follow-up hampered by too-safe choices. >>